20 Ways to Make Homemade Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Loss (suitable for all special diets)

Basic Green Thickie Recipe

20 Ways to Make Homemade Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Loss (suitable for all special diets)

I am so excited about this post.  It’s something I’ve wanted to do for a very long time as it makes all my recipes suitable for literally any type of special diet.

Don’t have time to read this post?  Download a handy print out to stick on your fridge so you know exactly what fillers to add to your smoothies to fill you up and help you lose weight.

If you are new to my website I’ll give you a bit of background.  The name, Green Thickie means a filling meal replacement smoothie which is a complete meal with optional greens to make it a Green Thickie.

When I first invented the Green Thickie, I started off adding oats

to my smoothies to turn them into meal replacement shakes.  After a while I started experimenting with other ingredients to make the smoothies thick and filling.  Now I’ve experimenting with grain free diets so I’ve just found a whole load more ingredients that make perfect additions to make homemade meal replacement shakes.

I also use my Green Thickies as a great tool for weight loss.

If you drink one Green Thickie for breakfast and another for lunch and a home cooked healthy dinner, you should see results when it comes to health and weight loss. Get started with Green Thickies here.

So if you are interested, any of the Green Thickie Recipes in my book can be used as meal replacement shakes for weight loss.

Green Thickies are designed to be the perfect meal for busy people.  If you don’t have time to sit down and eat a proper meal, you’ll get everything you need for one meal from a Green Thickie.  Because they are so filling I don’t usually feel the need to snack in between meals and nor do I have time to snack.  So I don’t have too many snack recipes on this website.

A lot of people ask me what else to eat besides Green Thickies, so I developed my 7 Day Detox for Weight Loss and Improved Health which will give you a full calorie counted meal plan to help you lose weight which incorporates some tasty recipes that aren’t published on this website.

Click here to have a look at Green Thickies 7 Day Detox.

So let me explain what makes a Green Thickie so powerful…. There are 6 ingredients in most green thickies.  The essential ingredients are:1) Liquid such as water, juice or dairy free milk2) Fruit/vegetables for nutrients. 3) I also add something sweet to my smoothies such as dried fruit to make them taste gorgeous.  4) I also add leafy greens as I believe eating leafy greens regularly takes your health to the next level.  5) To make them into a complete meal there are 2 more elements which are a protein source such as nuts or seeds 6) And finally, to make the green thickie filling, we need to add a filler. Keep reading to find out about fillers. I’m now going to explain the different choices of fillers you can add to your smoothie to make them into a complete meal.  And after I explain the fillers I’ll also give you a formula for making your own homemade meal replacement shakes for weight loss.

So now that I’ve explained the concept behind Green Thickies, I’m going to give you a list of ingredients that you can use to turn any smoothie into a filling meal replacement shake.

Each of my recipes serves 2, so all these fillers need to be added to a batch of smoothie that is enough for 2 portions.

How to add the fillers to smoothies to create Meal Replacement Meals

To make your own meal replacement shakes, you can either:

  • Use one of my recipes and add your choice of filler to it from the list below, or
  • Create your own smoothie with the template at the bottom of this post.

20 Fillers to turn any smoothie into Meal Replacement Shakes

Choose 1 from the following list to add to 1 serving of smoothie.

As most Green Thickies recipes serve 2, if you are following a Green Thickie recipe, choose 2 of these fillers below.

Please pin the image below or share it on your blog with a link back to this blog post.

20 Fillers to turn your smoothies into complete meals for weight loss

Fillers for Green Thickies

All of the following ingredients serve 2.  If you are making a smoothie for 1, use half of the amount listed below.

Raw Ingredients (Raw, Vegan, Paleo, Primal, Grain Free, Gluten Free, GAPs, SCD Diets)

1) 3 Medium Bananas/ 3 Cups of Banana Chunks (in addition to the bananas already in the recipe)*

2) 3 Small Mangos/ 3 Cups of Mango Chunks*

3) 1 Medium Avocado or 2 small avocados*

4) 4 Tablespoons Coconut Butter* (Get good quality Coconut Butter here) (low Carb)

5) 2/3 Cup of Coconut Milk from a Can* (Get good quality Coconut Milk here)

6) 4 Tablespoons of Coconut Cream* (Get good quality Coconut Cream here)(low Carb)

7)  3/4 cup Coconut Flour (Get good quality coconut flour here)

8) 3/4 cup Dried Fruit such as Dates, Raisins or other plain dried fruit (Get good quality dates here)

Nuts (Raw, Vegan, Paleo, Primal, Grain Free, Gluten Free, GAPs, SCD Diets)

9) 1/3 Cup Nuts (get good quality nuts here)

10) 3 Tablespoons Nut Butter*  (get good quality nut butter here)

Seeds (Raw, Vegan, Paleo, Primal, Grain Free, Gluten Free, GAPs, SCD Diets)

11) 1/2 Cup Seeds  (get good quality seeds here)

12) 3 Tablespoons Seed Butter*  (get good quality seed butter here)


13) 1 Cup of Oats (get good quality oats here)

14) 1 Cup of Quinoa (get good quality quinoa here)

15) 1 Cup of Buckwheat (get good quality buckwheat here)

Other Carbs (Vegan, Grain Free, Gluten Free)

16) 1 Cup Sweet Potato or White Potato*

17) 1.5 Cups cooked, drained White Beans 

18) 1 Cup Tofu (get good quality tofu here) *

19) 2 Cups of Soy Yogurt (Easily make your for pennies using soy beans) *

The Healthiest Smoothie Powders you will ever find

20) Homemade Smoothie Mix: For those lazy days where you don’t want to prepare any of the other fillers – or you want to add something bursting with nutrients, I’ve got something pretty special for you…  My 2 Minute Smoothie Powder Mix Homemade Hunger Buster is exactly what you’re looking for.  *

It takes just minutes to make a big batch of.  And if you leave a scoop in your mix, you just add this smoothie mix to your blender in seconds every time you make a smoothie.  Can’t get easier than that! Get this delicious smoothie mix recipe here. 

All of these fillers have roughly the same number of calories.  Each smoothie serves 2 so you would consume half of these fillers per smoothie.  This might seem a lot to you but remember, this is a complete meal, not a snack!  Some of them are bulkier than others so although each shake will be roughly a pint (500ml) some may be smaller and some larger, but all should fill you up until your next meal.

*I have added a star next to the fillers that are easiest to blend without a high speed blender.  All of the ingredients can be blended with any blender but it is easier to blend if you soak hard ingredients overnight first.  Another option is to grind your grains, nuts and seeds using your blending or coffee grinding before adding them to your smoothie.

I have chosen these fillers as most of them have a fairly neutral taste, and you’d be surprised how much the sweet fruit can overpower the taste of both the fillers and any greens you add to your smoothie.

Here is a handy chart to help you see at a glance which ingredients are suitable for your special diet:

Please pin this chart for later:

20 Ways to Make Homemade Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Loss

How to prepare the fillers for your meal replacement shakes

Most of the fillers can be added raw but to aid digestion, improve available nutrients and make the smoothies easier to blend it is advisable to prepare the fillers in the following ways:

  • Oats: Soak these in the smoothie liquid overnight and add straight to the blender (get good quality oats here)
  • Quinoa: Rinse then soak these in the smoothie liquid overnight and add straight to the blender.(get good quality quinoa here)
  • Buckwheat: Rinse these and continue to rinse every couple of hours for 8 hours then add straight to the blender.  (get good quality buckwheat here)
  • Sweet Potato: Cook this first by steaming it for 10 minutes or baking it for 20 minutes
  • White Potato: Steam this for 12 minutes and bake it under tender, about 45 minutes.
  • Cooked beans: Rinse canned beans or follow packet instructions to soak and cook dried beans.
  • Seeds and nuts: Soak over night, rinse and add to the blender.   (get good quality nuts and seeds here)
  • * If using dates or other dried fruit, it’s also good to soak these overnight in the smoothie liquid and add it all to the blender.

 How to make Homemade Meal Replacement Shakes for Weight Loss

How to make the perfect Healthy Smoothie

Here is a formula that you can you to make your own smoothie.  For more information on creating your own smoothie, please read How to make a Smoothie in 5 Easy Steps.

To make 2 servings of smoothie add the following ingredients:

  1. 2 Cups of Liquid
  2. 2 Cups of Fruit or if you are avoiding fruit, 2 cups of salad vegetables
  3. 1/4 Cup of Dried fruit or 2 Tablespoons of liquid sweetener such as Raw Honey or Maple Syrup
  4. 1/4 Cup of Nuts or Seeds or 2 Tablespoons of Nut/Seed Butter or other protein source such as 2 Tablespoons of Gelatin
  5. 1-2 Cups of mild leafy greens
  6. One of the fillers above

Remember – for homemade meal replacement shakes for weight loss drink 1 serving which is half of the above recipe formula.

This formula will make approximately 2 pints and to lose weight, drink 1 pint as a meal replacement.  Do this for breakfast and for lunch and then have a sensible dinner that is suitable for the particular diet you are following.  This is a great formula for weight loss.  For a complete meal plan – check out my 7 Day Diet Plan to boost your weight loss even more. If you get tired of having 2 sweet meal replacement shakes every day, make your first shake with fruit and your lunch shake with vegetables so you get a variety of fruit and vegetables in your diet. Have a look at my Vegetable smoothie and add your preferred filler to it.

Have you ever made your own meal replacement shakes? Please leave a comment below:

Would you like a printout of this post so you can stick it on your fridge and use it while you are making your smoothies? 

Just click here to download it now. 



Avatar for Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies

Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies

Founder at Green Thickies
Katherine lost 56 pounds and recovered from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome with Green Thickies.
Read Katherine's inspiring comeback story, From Fat and Fatigued To Lean and Loving Life In 4 Months.
Send Katherine a message on Instagram, Facebook, Google+, or email here.
Avatar for Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies

Latest posts by Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies (see all)

When I drink normal smoothies, they never filled me up, which led to binge eating and no weight loss.  So I created these homemade meal replacement shakes for weight loss which actually fill you up, reduce cravings and are tasty. I lost 56 pounds with these!  Check them out.  #greenthickies #smoothies #shakes #mealreplacementshakes #weightloss #weightlosssmoothies

Brand New Recipe Book: FREE Today Only!

Download 9 Gorgeous Green Smoothies

9 Gorgeous Green Smoothie Recipes

Only available FREE for a limited time...

Woohoo!.... You Get To Swipe 9 Of My Life Changing Fat Blasting Green Smoothies FREE Today Only! Drink one Green Thickie recipe every morning for 9 days and watch your life change for the better!

You'll feel lighter, happier, with more energy and motivation than you've ever have before with less cravings and hunger.

Click here to download your FREE copy.

Download 9 Gorgeous Green Smoothies
I join the following blog parties every week.


  1. I definitely need to make some of these after yesterday’s food fest. Which would be good to start with? I ate too much and feel bloated and fat! Why I ate like, I don’t know. Even desserts, which I never do. Well, I may not eat the rest of the year.

  2. Can you use cooked white rice/brown rice as a filled? If so, how many cups? Thanks

  3. I was wondering why yogurt and kefir are not included in the list. They make great smoothies.

  4. Hi Just to get it clear in my head – I need to add nuts and/or seed and a filler – the nuts/seeds are not a filler?

  5. Hello,
    Just out of curiosity.. why are there no berries used in these recipes? It seems to be the same, 3 or 4 fruits used in all of the recipes. I was hoping to see some actual vegetables incorporated into the smoothies, like zucchini, cucumber and ginger. Is there a reason why you omitted a variety of fruits and veggies in your 7 day plan?

  6. I love the chart with all the different ingredients! It’s very helpful and easy to use, so thank you very much!

  7. Avatar for Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies Gabriela says:

    I made my smoothie with greens, fruits, orange juice, pecans and oatmeal. How do I know how many calories I consumed?

  8. Hi, I actually need to gain weight in order to be healthy. I am having problems meeting my calorie and macronutrient daily goals (2000 to 2500 calories a day) due to not having access to lots of good foods, not having a lot of different food options, not having enough time to eat, or not being home to eat. Would it be okay to use these meal replacement shakes in another way, which would be to supplement my other meals so I can get closer to my daily calorie and macronutrient requirements and have something to give me nutrients and energy when I’m not home and don’t have enough food for the day? Can I drink these in addition to my other regular meals/snacks, because what I’m currently eating isn’t enough to meet my daily requirements? Thanks in advance for any advice!

  9. Avatar for Katherine Kyle @ Green Thickies Denise Stephenson says:

    Has anybody used the Kitchen Aid blender before to make their Green Thickies and smoothies? I have been reading through the site and keep seeing a different order of ingredients. Liquid and dry first then greens, filler , etc. i also read another part of the site says liquid then greens, then fillers, and fruit. Confusing. I just need to know before I waste ingredients and money trying to blend a smoothie. I tried something like this a few years agoo and never liked anything mixed together. All to the consistency of applesauce.

    • I think it does depend on your blender and the recipe, I’d recommend making each Green Thickie as described in the recipe.

  10. Please give chia a try. Soak 1-2 tbs in smoothie liquid for 15 minutes to overnight. Blend thoroughly into smoothie. Very good protein, essential fatty acids, fiber and a great thickener.

  11. How long can I store my shakes in the fridge before they go bad?

  12. How many scoops of protein powder should you use for a filler, also keeping in mind that your recipes have 2 servings? I want enough calories but not too much…

  13. wow! This Homemade Meal Replacement Shakes looks is really awesome. I think it is very effective for make the Smoothie for weight loss…! thanks for share…

  14. Hi, I really need to try this after days of not being able to sit properly during meal time with two kids in tow. Ingredients are possible to find at my local market. I have few concerns:
    1) Can i have it for dinner instead of lunch? It’s dinner that i usually don’t have time for.
    2) I’m confused with the filler. Let’s say I make a big batch for 30 days and how much do i put in for 1 serving of smoothie? 1/4 cup of filler for each green thickies’ smoothie recipe and it makes 2 servings? And then ‘1/2 cup for the whole batch’?
    I’d like to prepare fillers for the whole month & make 1 serving of smoothie at a time.

    Thank you so much :)

  15. Hello. I have a vary bad snacking problem and it doesn’t help that I work late and we sell candy only at my work,so when I get hungry you know. I have dried doing smoothies before and it went pretty well but I am just not sure on what to put in mine. I have a big sweet tooth but I like veggies :). Are there any tips that any one can give me for making a not so bitter shake? Thank you

  16. Yummy!! I really enjoyed your green thickie recipes,I personally like everything green!! I personally feel better every time I drink or eat something green lol.
    Another smoothie I really enjoy making often is mixing banana,avocado,chia seeds,spinach,and pure almond milk.It comes out soooooo gooooood should give it a try

Speak Your Mind